[redsox12]

Well they are both amazing and I would choose both of them; but since you're asking for 1...I would choose Curt cause he is very dominant and he won't give up and loves the game. Plus; I'm a Red Sox fan.

[Jacquot]

Curt Schilling. He is a jerk but I think perhaps the best big game pitcher of the past 10 years.

Johnson is awesome as well, but if I had to have ONE pitcher for ONE big money game it would be Schilling.

[Chipmaker]

Johnson.

Unit pitched a perfect game once. That HAS to be his absolute best.

[Chipmaker]

Johnson.

Unit pitched a perfect game once. That HAS to be his absolute best.

[Ian B]

If i were to have one in the regular season, give me johnson in a heartbeat. But in the playoffs i would take schilling possibly over anybody thats ever played the game.